Migration Agent vs Immigration Lawyer: Which Do You Actually Need?

Many people assume a migration agent and an immigration lawyer are the same thing at two different prices. But even though both can legally help with your visa, a lawyer can do a few things an agent can't.

This guide explains the difference between them, including what each can do and how to tell which one your situation calls for.

It also covers a third option. At Matilda, you can work with a migration agent and a lawyer under one roof, so you  might not even need to make a choice between the two.

If you're still deciding whether to seek help at all, start with our comparison of DIY applications vs using a migration agent or immigration lawyer.

How the Two Professions Differ

Both a migration agent and an immigration lawyer can handle your visa application from start to finish. But the lawyer is also able to provide legal advice, handle complex or disputed immigration matters and represent you in court.

Both are legally allowed to charge money to help people with their visa. The Migration Act stipulates that only a registered migration agent or an Australian legal practitioner  can give paid immigration assistance.

One thing that used to cause confusion is that until March 2021, a lawyer doing migration work also had to register as a migration agent. This is no longer the case and the two are now separate. A person is either a registered migration agent or a lawyer, not both.

What a Migration Agent Can Do

A migration agent can advise you on your options, prepare and lodge your application and deal with the Department of Home Affairs for you. If your visa is refused, they can also represent you at the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART), which is the independent body that reviews the original decision of the Department.

What an agent can't do is represent you in a court, or keep your communications legally protected (that protection is called “legal professional privilege”, and only lawyers have it).

Migration agents are registered with OMARA, the industry regulator, and follow a set code of conduct.

What an Immigration Lawyer Can Do That an Agent Can't

A lawyer can do everything an agent can, plus three things an agent can't:

• Represent you in court if your case goes beyond the ART (for example, in the Federal Circuit and Family Court)
• Keep your communications legally protected
• Advise you on legal problems connected to your visa, such as a character issue under section 501 of the Migration Act, or how a refusal affects a family law or criminal matter.

The ART replaced the older Administrative Appeals Tribunal in October 2024.

Migration Agent vs Immigration Lawyer: Side-by-Side Comparison

‍

How the Costs Compare

A migration agent is usually the cheaper option for straightforward applications, because their scope and training are narrower than a lawyer's. A lawyer costs more when there's legal argument, an appeal or court involved.

The price depends on the visa and how complex your case is, not just the job title of your agent or lawyer. Matilda publishes flat fees by visa type on its pricing FAQ.

When You Actually Need a Lawyer

You need a lawyer rather than an agent when there's a real legal problem, not just a complicated form. Consider one if your situation involves:

• A previous visa refusal or cancellation
• A character issue (for example, a criminal record) under section 501
• An appeal that may go past the ART into a court
• Disputed facts the department is likely to examine closely, such as conflicting evidence about a relationship or job history
• An overlap with family, criminal or workplace law
• A need to keep sensitive communications legally protected.

Using a Migration Agent and a Lawyer Together

For anything beyond a straightforward application, using both together is often the best option. You get migration advice and legal input on the same case, without having to find a second firm halfway through.

That's the gap Matilda Migration is built to close: our lawyer-credentialled team pairs lawyers with registered migration agents in the same practice.

If a legal issue comes up mid-application, you don't have to start again elsewhere. For matters that end up needing court representation, Matilda works with a trusted network of external legal professionals.

How to Check Someone Is Legitimately Registered

• For a migration agent: Search their Migration Agent Registration Number (MARN) on the OMARA public register
• For a lawyer: Search their name on the law society register in their state (for example, the Law Society of NSW or the Victorian Legal Services Board).

Anyone charging for visa help who isn't on one of these registers is acting outside the law.

‍Matilda Tip: Ask for a MARN or practising certificate number before you engage anyone, and check it yourself. It takes two minutes and it's the best protection against unregistered “consultants”.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the Difference Between a Migration Agent and an Unregistered “Visa Consultant”?

A registered migration agent has a Migration Agent Registration Number (MARN) and is regulated by OMARA. An unregistered “visa consultant” has neither, and legally can't charge you for immigration help. If something goes wrong, there's no complaints process and no professional insurance behind them.

Can a Migration Agent Represent Me in Court?

No. An agent can represent you at the Administrative Review Tribunal, but only a lawyer can appear for you in a court.

How Do I Complain About a Migration Agent or Lawyer?

For an agent, complain through OMARA. It can investigate conduct, but can't order a refund or change your visa decision. For a lawyer, complain to the legal regulator in their state (for example, in Victoria, that would be the Victorian Legal Services Board).

Can an Agent or Lawyer Help Me Apply From Outside Australia?

Yes. Both can act for you if you're offshore, and some visas (like the offshore partner visas) are designed to be lodged from outside Australia. An agent or lawyer located in Australia can also help you with an offshore application. 

Does Using a Lawyer Improve My Chances of Approval?

Neither an agent nor a lawyer can guarantee an outcome or speed up processing  (Home Affairs is clear on that). What good help does is reduce the risk of an avoidable refusal by making sure your application is complete, well-evidenced and deals with any legal issues before you lodge.

Make the Right Choice for You

For most straightforward applications, a registered migration agent is the right, lower-cost choice. Bring in a lawyer when your case carries real legal risk.

And if you'd rather not judge that yourself, a team like Matilda, with both under one roof, means the right expertise is already on your file. We charge a flat fee that doesn’t differentiate between agents and lawyers, so it is not more expensive to work with us.

‍For applicants: Take Matilda's eligibility quiz to book a free, no-obligation consultation and find out what level of support you need.

‍For employers: If you're sponsoring overseas talent and want compliance advice alongside application support, check your options for employer-sponsored visas.‍

This is general information, not personal migration advice.